Re: [sig-policy] Proposal 99
Hi，Sanjaya and All,
Thanks. An additional note:
With these definition, can we simplify Section 9.2 (2nd scenario)?
9.2. Special circumstances
An LIR may request an exception to the HD 0.94 rule when:
* It has a demonstrated need for an assignment that is larger than
the amount of remaining space,
* It is announcing its existing IPv6 allocation and can demonstrate
a need or requirement to build discrete networks to be advertised
under different ASNs,
* It requires the additional allocation for technical reasons such
as for IPv4 to IPv6 transitional technologies, or
* It can demonstrate other reasons accepted by APNIC as valid
circumstance, or in accord with applicable policies.
I suggest to change to:
* It is announcing its existing IPv6 allocation and can demonstrate a
need or requirement to build discrete networks,
.....
Discrete Networks
-----------------
Where an organization demonstrates a compelling need, or requirement, to
build discrete networks due to regulatory, geographic, or operational
reasons and these multihomed networks are advertised either internally,
or externally, the network may be defined by APNIC as being composed of
discrete networks.
Otherwise, it may be a little bit unclear.
When you updated the IPv6 Guideline Document, please send me a note and
I will refer to the url and formally withdraw prop-099.
Best regards,
xing
Sanjaya 写道:
Dear Xing,
Thank you for your comment. I have no issues with your suggested
wording. It covers the cases we saw in the large network requests.
Cheers,
Sanjaya
On 4/08/2012 3:05 AM, Xing Li wrote:
Hi，Sanjaya and All,
Thanks for your work. I think adding a definition of 'discrete networks'
to the IPv6 Guideline Document can achieve the goal of pro-099.
However, the wording of "with separate ASNs" is somehow confusing.
I suggest to remove the word of "with separate ASNs", since "the
prefixes of these multihomed networks can be advertised either
internally, or externally, with SAME ASN or separate ASNs".
So my suggested wordings are:
Discrete Networks
-----------------
Where an organization demonstrates a compelling need, or requirement, to
build discrete networks due to regulatory, geographic, or operational
reasons and these multihomed networks are advertised either internally,
or externally, the network may be defined by APNIC as being composed of
discrete networks.
Any comments or corrections?
Best regards,
xing