Hi Dean and all,Transfer is essentially re-delegation process and the IPv4 policy is quite specific in delegation size based on 1 year need:
"Based on these factors, APNIC and NIRs will delegate address space to meet the LIR's estimated needs for a period up to one year up to the maximum allowed delegation under Section 3. If APNIC or the NIR make a delegation based on a period of less than one year, then they must inform the LIR of the length of the period and the reasons for selecting it."
I don't see ways to accommodate prop-104 need without changing the policy. The needs based transfer evaluation introduced by prop-096 must have boundaries. Otherwise, as per Adam's latest post to the list, people may come with a 15 year or 100 year planning window that would be hard to decline.
Regards, Sanjaya On 31/07/2012 1:05 PM, Dean Pemberton wrote:
Good Afternoon, A lot of this policy looks to compare the current APNIC situation with that in other RIRs, I do not believe a difference in itself is a reason to change policy. Just because it is done differently elsewhere, while interesting, should not be a necessary and sufficient condition for policy change within this region. Therefore the justification for this policy really boils down to:Furthermore, 12 months is also too short for transfers within the APNIC region considering many xSPs plan their service and their addressing requirements beyond one year.As with prop-99. I'd like to ask Sanjaya, is there a way to accomodate this situation under the current policies. For example, If a user were able to justify their needs for a two year period, would the hostmasters support a transfer under the current policies. We can then see if there appears to be a problem. Kind Regards, Dean
- Prev by Date: Re: [sig-policy] Proposal 99
- Next by Date: Re: [sig-policy] prop-104-v001: Clarifying demonstrated needs requirement in IPv4 transfer policy
- Previous by thread: Re: [sig-policy] Proposal 99
- Next by thread: Re: [sig-policy] prop-104-v001: Clarifying demonstrated needs requirement in IPv4 transfer policy