Elvis and all, Sorry for late reply, but I had a chance to talk with some of ARIN AC members and ARIN staff, so let me share their feedbacks. 1. It is ARIN staffs' responsibility to show the implications of current ARIN policy and they think current proposed idea on apnic-talk, which removes DN only from Intra-RIR transfer, is not compatible with ARIN transfer policy as it is, since ARIN requires DN for both of Inter and Intra RIR transfer case. 2. Even if ARIN staff would think it is compatible, ARIN community may raise a issue that it can be used to milk ARIN's remaining pool. So, adding more restrictions for Intra-RIR transfer of address spaces which were transferred from other RIRs (e.g. DN requirement, 12months restriction) may be helpful to relax their concern. 3. ARIN's concern for milking is applicable only before the exhaustion of their remaining pool and it is expected to happen at the end of this year or the beginning of next year. So, we may see different discussion after that. I hope it helps your understanding and discussion. Rgs, Masato Yamanishi On 14/06/04 7:39, "Elvis Velea" <elvis at velea dot eu> wrote:
|