[sig-policy]Belief summary of 7th Address Policy SIG
Thank you for your participation in 7th Address Policy SIG
where we had 12 topics in 3 sessions.
Long, tough but fruitful discussions reached several rough consensus.
Here is a quick and belief summary. Please refer to meeting minutes
for more details which will be coming soon.
- SIG co-chairs election
Yong Wan Ju and Kenny Huang elected out of three candidates.
- Policy development process
Anne Lord, Ray Plzak, Randy Bush
- Widen the opportunity for discussion
- Minimum ML discussion period needed both before and after
If not sufficient before the meeting, no decision in the meeting
should allowed and more discussion needed in the ML afterwards
- Full text format needed for proposal
- Final approval issue will be carried over to AMM
- General agreement in principle and more discussion needed
- IPv6 space management
Paul Wilson
- No objection about general direction
- More discussion needed
These are not consensus but some useful inputs.
- IPv6 policy revision
David Kessens
- Editorial committee to collect various voices and compile them
into an revision item list
- Keep discussing
- 2.0.0.2.ip6.arpa issue
Randy Bush
- Some people support the general idea that a reverse delegation
for 6to4 is useful provided by RIRs, but a comment was made
that there might be some fee structure for end users
to cover the cost if it is implemented
- 223.255.255.0/24 issue
Anne Lord
- Many different opinions about how to solve the procedural problem.
- This is an operational issue between IANA and APNIC
There were other interesting presentations. Find more in the APNIC web pages.
Finally, the followings were open action items checked at the meeting.
All items were finished.
- Action add-14-001:
Secretariat to release ASN policy draft for an additional final round of comments
- Action add-14-002:
Secretariat to take steps to implement the experimental allocation proposal.
- Action add-14-003:
Secretariat to implement the LIR sub-allocation proposal
- Action add-14-004:
Secretariat to provide supporting documentation to assist LIRs in evaluating
allocation sizes
- Action add-14-005:
Secretariat to discuss the IPv6 documentation proposal with other RIRs
to determine the details of the range to be used
- Action add-14-006:
Secretariat to provide feedback of the 6bone migration proposal discussion
to the 6bone community
- Action add-14-007:
Secretariat to provide feedback of the APNIC discussion on RFC2050 revision
to the appropriate mailing lists
As the discussion above suggests, I am looking forward to seeing
more discussion occur in the mailing list. Any questions and comments
are welcome. Thanks.
Regards,
Takashi Arano
Address Policy SIG chair