Orbit


                        Hi Scott,
...
Would there be any penalties for failure to update contact information?
I was planning to do add some penalties, but I changed my mind and
thought it would be better to talk about the proposal first and hoped
that people will ask exactly this question. Thank you  ;-)
I think the ARIN approach is pretty good.
https://www.arin.net/policy/nrpm.html#three6
I would just do one thing different. Offer 2 lists:
1.) Unresponsive as- or inet(6)nums
2.) Known wrong contact information
That way everybody in the world can download these files and decide by
him self what to do with this information. I bet there will be some
people in the world greylisting IPs in their mail infrastructure, ...
That should be penalty enough and we do not have to face the problem,
that APNIC should not punish members directly.
Thanks,
Tobias

Orbit

Activity Summary